ReplayGain 2.0 specification

This is a proposed update to the ReplayGain 1.0 specification. This proposal is currently Under Construction. Please discuss this proposal on the discussion page or the General Audio forum. --Notat 23:42, 8 October 2012 (CEST)

ReplayGain 2.0 (RG2) is a proposed update to the ReplayGain 1.0 (RG1) specification from 2001 originally published by David Robinson. RG2 features an updated loudness measurement technique which better simulates human auditory perception of digital music. This improved measurement enables more accurate gain adjustment during playback to achieve better perceived consistent loudness when listening to digital music from different albums and sources.

This proposed RG2 specification includes:

• a way to measure and calculate the apparent loudness of a given track or album (#Loudness Measurement)
• definition of appropriate reference level and ideal gain adjustment during playback (#Reference Level and Gain)
• practical considerations for loudness level in real world use (#Pre-amplification)
• a way to prevent clipping when the calculated replay gain exceeds the limits of digital audio (#Clipping Prevention)
• a method for the user to specify album vs. track gain adjustment at playback (#Track or Album Gain Adjustment)
• description of how replay gain information is stored within audio files (#Metadata)

Note to End Users: Any software program or device which supports playback of original ReplayGain (RG1) scanned tracks should also play ReplayGain 2 (RG2) scanned tracks at the intended RG2 loudness level. More information for end users on music scanning and playback can be found in the general Wikipedia page for ReplayGain 2.

Loudness Measurement

The original ReplayGain 1.0 specification relied on the Root Mean Square (RMS) method of calculation to perform (a now more primitive form of) loudness measurement. ReplayGain 2.0 loudness measurement and calculation is based on the ITU BS. 1770-2 standard as defined by the International Telecom Union (ITU) for broadcast audio. Details about the loudness measurement algorithm, rationale, and supporting data were published by the ITU in March 2011. In summary, BS. 1770-2 uses the K-weighting system to model human perceived loudness of audio.

The ITU BS. 1770-2 standard has been adopted in the United States by the ATSC as A/85 and in Europe by the European Broadcast Union as EBU R-128 for broadcast audio. It is expected the ITU standard will evolve over time to meet the needs of broadcasters and governments. It was given a minor update, published as BS. 1770-3 in August 2012, but the change had no effect on the Replay Gain 2.0 specification or loudness measurement for digital music.

Reference Level and Gain

The initial ReplayGain 1.0 in 2001 specification adapted the SMPTE standard reference level for movie sound of 83db SPL (-20 dbFS), and was subsequently updated to target 89db SPL (-14 dbFS) by David Robinson. The ReplayGain 2.0 target reference level is based on the research and findings of Martin Wolters, Harald Mundt, and Jeffrey Riedmiller of Dolby Laboratories as published in May 2010 for the Audio Engineering Society. Since RG2 is based on ITU BS. 1770-2 which specifies a target loudness reference of -23 LKFS, the calculation to determine the gain of ReplayGain is as follows (from page 11 of the 2010 Dolby paper):

Therefore the following reversible conversion between Replay Gain and ITU-based loudness is proposed:
RG = -18db - L
where RG is the estimated Replay Gain and L is the Loudness according to ITU-R BS.1770 in LKFS (dB relative full scale).

In general, the adjusted playback loudness using RG2 will be lower than RG1, but will have better perceived loudness consistency from track to track.

Player requirements

Figure 8: Example ReplayGain control panel

Pre-amplification

Although the calibration level used by ReplayGain suggests that the average level of an audio track should be -23db LKFS, some pop music is dynamically compressed to peak at 0 dB and average around 3 dB below full scale. This means that, when the replay gain is applied, the level of such tracks will be reduced by 18 dB! If users are listening to a mixture of highly compressed and more dynamic tracks, ReplayGain will make the listening experience more pleasurable by bringing the level of the compressed tracks down into line with that of the others. However, if users are only listening to highly compressed music, then they may complain that all their files are now too quiet.

To address this problem, a pre-amp feature should be incorporated into the player. A user-supplied pre-amp setting is an adjustment to the calculated replay gain. It should default to perform no adjustment. This means that casual users will experience a moderate reduction in the loudness of their compressed pop music. Less-compressed material can generally be played at the same loudness without clipping. Normalization of more dynamic material may cause clipping or invoke the clipping prevention mechanism (see below). Power users and audiophiles can reduce the pre-amp gain to enjoy the full dynamic range of all of their music.

If enabled, the player should read the user selected pre-amp gain, and scale the audio signal by the appropriate amount. For example, a +6 dB gain requires a scale of 10^6/20, which is approximately 2. The replay gain and pre-amp scale factors can be combined for simplicity and ease of processing.

Clipping prevention

ITU BS. 1770-2 suggestion of a -23 LKFS average playback level leaves sufficient headroom for the bulk of modern recordings. Nevertheless, there exists the possibility that after application of replay gain and pre-amp adjustment, a track may exceed full scale during its dynamic peaks. Without intervention, this will result in clipping, a severe form of distortion. Factors introducing the possibility of clipping include:

1. Recordings from certain genres and certain periods in the history or commercial recordings require additional headroom. Although these recordings can be accommodated through a downwards adjustment of the pre-amp setting, it may be difficult to determine a safe adjustment and it may be undesirable to lower average level to accommodate the rare track which requires it.
2. ReplayGain will make loud dynamically compressed tracks quieter, and quiet dynamically uncompressed tracks louder. The average levels will then be similar, but the quiet tracks will actually have louder peaks. If the user pushes the pre-amp gain upwards the peaks of the (originally) quieter tracks will be pushed well over full scale.
3. In coded audio (e.g. MP3 files) a file that was hard-limited to digital full scale before encoding will often be pushed over the limit by the psychoacoustic compression. A decoder with headroom can recover the over full scale signal by reducing the gain.

ReplayGain suggests two possible solutions which prevent clipping in these situations. A player should support one or both of these.

Audio limiting

In situation 2 above, the user clearly wants all the music to sound very loud. To give them their wish, any signal which would peak above digital full scale should be hard limited at just below digital full scale. This is also useful at lower pre-amp gains, where it allows the average level of classical music to be raised to that of pop music, without distorting. The exact type of nature limiting or compression an implementation choice for the player.

Reduced gain

The audiophile user will not want any compression or limiting on the signal. In this case the only option is to automatically and temporarily reduce the pre-amp gain below the user-selected setting for tracks where clipping would otherwise occur. Clipping can be predicted by examining the peak level of the track or album being played.

The player must read the peak amplitude metadata. If peak level metadata is unavailable, the player should assume a peak level of 1.0. If the peak level for both track and album is stored as metadata in the file, it is possible to calculate if, following the replay gain adjustment and pre-amp gain, the signal will clip at some point. If it won't, then no further action is necessary.

An overall scale factor for loudness normalization taking into account replay gain, pre-amp setting and clipping prevention through gain reduction is given below.

$min(10^{\frac {RG+G_{pre-amp}}{20}},{\frac {1}{peakamplitude}})$

Track or Album Gain Adjustment

To properly normalize loudness, the player needs to determine if the user desires Track style level normalization (all tracks same loudness), or Album style level normalization (all albums same loudness, tracks of an album played at the same relative level as on the original release). This option should be selectable in the ReplayGain control panel (Figure 8). The player reads the corresponding gain metadata value from the file and scales the audio data as appropriate. Scaling the audio data simply means multiplying each sample value by a constant value. This constant is given by:

$10^{\frac {gain}{20}}$

Or, in words, replay gain divided by 20 all raised to the power of ten.

If the file only contains one of the replay gain adjustments (e.g. Album) but the user has requested the other (Track), then the player should use the one that is available (in this case, Album). If neither (Track or Album) gain metadata is available, then the player needs to choose a suitable default gain. Potential choices include unity gain (0 dB) or an average of gains from other tracks in the album or playlist.

Metadata

For ReplayGain to do its work during playback, four values must be stored as metadata with or within the audio file:

1. Peak track amplitude
2. Peak album amplitude
3. Track replay gain
4. Album replay gain

If calculated for an individual track, the loudness measurement (as specified above) yields track replay gain. If calculated on an album basis, with all tracks concatenated to make one long audio file, the loudness measurement yields album replay gain.

Replay gain

Under some listening conditions, it's useful to have every track sound equally loud. The problem with a track-by-track approach is that tracks which should be quiet in the context of the album on which they reside will be brought up to the level of all the rest. For casual listening, or in a noisy background, this can be a good thing. For serious listening, it does not respect the intent of the artist or mastering engineer; a tender ballad track will be blasting at the same loudness as a hard rock track on the same album. It's generally ideal to leave the intentional loudness differences between tracks in place, yet still correct for unmusical and annoying loudness differences between albums. To accomplish this, ReplayGain suggests that two different gain adjustments should be stored as metadata with each sound file.

Album replay gain represents the ideal listening gain for an entire album. ReplayGain reads the collection of tracks that comprise a album, and calculates a single replay gain for the whole set. This single can be used for playback of all tracks of the album. Intentionally quiet tracks then stay appropriately quieter than the rest. It still solves the basic problem (annoying, unwanted level differences between discs) because quiet or loud discs are still adjusted overall—so the pop CD that's 20 dB louder than the classical CD will be brought into line.

Peak amplitude

Scanning a track or album for the peak amplitude can be a time-consuming process. Therefore, it's helpful if this single value is stored as metadata. This is used to predict whether the required replay gain adjustment will cause clipping during playback.

The maximum peak amplitude value is stored as a floating point number, where 1.0 represents digital full scale. As with replay gain values, separate peak amplitude values are stored per track and per album.

For uncompressed files simply, scanners store the maximum absolute sample value held in the file on any channel for positive or negative excursion. The single sample value should be converted to a floating-point representation, such that digital full scale is equivalent to a value of 1.0.

Psychoacoustically coded audio, such as MP3, does not exist as a sequence of samples until it is decoded. Psychoacoustic coding of a heavily limited file can lead to sample values larger than digital full scale upon decoding. The coded files must be decoded using a fully compliant decoder that allows peak overflows (i.e. has headroom) and may result in peak amplitude values greater than 1.0.

Metadata format

From the standpoint of metadata storage, each audio file format presents a unique situation. There are three favored schemes defined for storage of ReplayGain metadata: ID3v2, Vorbis comments and APEv2. A survey of file formats is listed below with metadata schemes in order of preference for each:

• .aac (Advanced Audio Coding raw format) – No metadata support (use .mp4 instead)
• .aiff, .aif, .aifc (Apple Interchange File Format) – ID3v2 (in "ID3" IFF chunk)
• .ape, .apl (Monkey's Audio) – APEv2
• .bwf (Broadcast Wave Format) – ID3v2 (in RIFF chunk)
• .flac (Free Lossless Audio Codec) – Vorbis comments
• .mp3 (MPEG audio layer 3) – ID3v2, LAME VBR proposed tag specification
• .mp4 also .m4a, .m4b, .m4p, m4r (MPEG-4 Part 14) – ID3v2 (in "ID32" box)
• .mpc (Musepack) – APEv2
• .ogg (Ogg Vorbis) – Vorbis comments
• .tta (True Audio) – ID3v2, APEv2
• .wma (Windows Media audio) - Advanced Systems Format (not supported by ReplayGain)
• .wav (Windows PCM) – No metadata support (use .bwf instead)
• .wv (WavePak) – APEv2

ID3v2

The ID3v2 standard defines a tag which is situated before the data in an MP3 file. ID3 is used primarily with MP3 audio files but means of adapting the system to other file types have been developed.

The ID3v2 tag is divided into frames. The preferred means of storing ReplayGain metadata is use of TXXX key/value pair frames. Two other legacy schemes for storing ReplayGain metadata exist: RGAD and RVA2. These formats are documented in the appendix. Players may choose to look for these formats if metadata in the TXXX format is not found in the ID3v2 tag. New scanners may write these older formats in addition to the newer (TXXX) ones if they wish to remain backwards compatible with older players.

ReplayGain uses four TXXX frames. The header of a TXXX frame is coded as follows:

Frame ID       $54 58 58 58 ("TXXX") 
Size           $xx xx xx xx (size of frame excluding this header)
Flags          $40 $00      (discard frame if audio data is altered)

Frame data is coded as follows:

Text encoding  $00          (ISO-8859-1 encoding)
Description    <key string> $00
Value          <value string>

The four frames associated with ReplayGain metadata use the following key/value pairs

Table 3: Metadata keys and value formatting

Metadata	Key	Value format
Track replay gain	REPLAYGAIN_TRACK_GAIN	[-]a.bb dB
Peak track amplitude	REPLAYGAIN_TRACK_PEAK	c.dddddd
Album replay gain	REPLAYGAIN_ALBUM_GAIN	[-]a.bb dB
Peak album amplitude	REPLAYGAIN_ALBUM_PEAK	c.dddddd

Gains are specified textually in decibels. Negative gains (attenuation) are prefixed with a '-'. Positive gains have no prefix. Integral portion of the gain (a) may be one or two numeric (0-9) digits. If there is no integral portion the field is '0'. The decimal portion of the gain (bb) is two numeric digits. Gains are suffixed with a space followed by 'dB'.

Peak levels are specified textually as a positive decimal. Peak level is a dimensionless quantity with 1.000000 representing full scale. No suffix is included on peak values. The integer field (c) is typically 1 or 0. Six numeric digits in the decimal field (dddddd) is adequate to accurately represent peak values for 16-bit audio data.

A robust player should be prepared to parse the following variations in either replay gain or peak level metadata:

• Positive gains with leading '+'
• More or fewer significant digits than specified in any field
• Leading zeros or spaces in integer fields
• Missing or malformed 'dB' suffix (e.g. no space between numeric digits and suffix, alternate capitalization)
• Alternate capitalization of keys

Other formatting errors indicate more severe problems and should result in player ignoring data as if the frame did not exist.

Vorbis comments

A Vorbis comment uses an ASCII key=value format. When Vorbis comments are used, the four ReplayGain metadata items are stored as separate comments. The keys and formatting for values is the same as specified for ID3v2. Keys and values are required by the Vorbis comment specification to b separated by '=' (equal character).

APEv2

The APEv2 metadata format also organizes data into key/value pairs. Keys are ASCII format. A flags field allows support for several value formats including UTF-8 and binary. Under APEv2, ReplayGain meta data is stored using the same keys and data as ASCII values in the same format as specified for ID3v2.

Acknowledgements

The original ReplayGain proposal (an archive is also available) was developed by David Robinson and was published 10 July 2001. Additional updates were published by David Robinson through 10 October 2001.

The following acknowledgement was included with the original proposal, "The algorithm to calculate an ideal replay gain has grown from my research into human hearing, with many additional ideas drawn from the work of E. Zwicker, and Brian Moore. I am currently completing my PhD at the University of Essex, and have been funded by the EPSRC." Additionally David Robinson credited Glen Sawyer (Snelg) and Jim Casaburi (Walrus) for software contributions and Bob Katz and Matt Ashland for ideas.

The updated ReplayGain 1.0 specification reflecting recommended practice was prepared by Kevin Gross in 2011.

Contact

For ReplayGain-related questions or contributions, please post in the General Audio section of the Hydrogen Audio forums.

Appendix

1. ReplayGain legacy metadata formats